well, after reading and using the forum's help we made a reservation for Glory, oct 08. we read all about pre paid tipping. For a big family like ours (4 kids) it is a lot of money- more than 400$. Ofcourse we do want to tip, and we understand it is their salary, but our salary is also not thet high. we have saved a long time to give the kids this present trip. is it possible not to prepay but to tip those who you really want to tip? I assume that some of the answers will be angry ones, but not all passanger on board are rich...
Yes, tipping is a touchy subject. While I don't advocate NOT tipping (unless there is a reason) I certainly can understand the finance pressure behind your concerns. I'll try to be non-judgmental in my reply.
To answer your question- No, you do NOT have to prepay the tips (at time of booking). They WILL however charge your sign and sail account the first day with the "recommended" amount (The $400). You have the option of going to the purser's desk (or guest relations desk as it is sometimes called) at any time during your cruise and adjusting these amounts. You could have them all pulled off and then add back in the ones you want. Or adjust the amounts up and down but keep the total the same. You will have a hard time getting the 15% tips removed for the bar and spa receipts, so you can decide if that is worth the hassle. But be prepared for a hassle. Sometimes they will adjust tips without a big deal and sometimes you are treated like you are stealing money from the cruise line. Tips are tips. If the service doesn't warrant a tip, then you shouldn't have to give one. But, the crew's income does come mainly from tips. Realize that with 6 of you, the staff is going to be working harder to keep your cabin neat than a 2 person cabin. You should not completely stiff the staff that is serving you... everyone should get something, but I'll leave what that is up to you.
CCL Fantasy 1990 CCL Celebration 1995 CCL Victory 2005 CCL Conquest 2005 CCL Spirit June 2006 NCL Dream October 2006 RCCL Mariner OTS June 2007 CCL Freedom June 2008 CCL Holiday July 2008
An important thing to remember is that the list of those who rely on tips for the income is not that long. Excluding the bar and spa staffs, for years the primary tip list was the cabin attendant, the waiter, and busboy. That was it. Within the past decade most cruise lines added the head waiter (or maitre'd) to the list, and some added the chief housekeeper. Many cruisers will not tip those latter additions unless they do something special for you, and I don't include shaking your hand as something special.
I would be hard pressed to decide "who I really wanted to tip" because they all work for it and work very hard. Who gets less than the suggested amount, which is really considered the minimum? And looking at the big picture, you have 6 guests being waited on for a week. That is a lot of service.
Jamjam, I certainly am not rich and certainly do have to watch my every cent, but I would never NOT tip. If you've ever cruised, you know how hard the crew work. If this is your first cruise, you will understand your first day on board. With 6 people to wait on, that's a lot of work. Let your conscience be your guide. As Jim said, you can remove the tips, if that is what you choose to do. I think once you see how hard everyone works, you'll find another way to save a few extra dollars.
I am going to jump in here on the tipping issue. As a lump sum it might seem high, but on a daily basis it not. These people work very very hard to make your stay a wonderful experience. We have never ever requested something from our room steward that we didnt have within minutes. We have never asked for seconds or an extra meal at the dining room that it was not brought to us with a smile. We are not drinkers so we never had to worry about the 15% added to a bar tab. one thing that we dont do is tip the matre de. some people do, we just dont.
On the subject of tipping! How much do you generally tip? Come from a country that doesnt having tipping generally where waiters etc are paid a wage what is the general tip.
I know there wages are low and based on tips but how much. It could become preety expensive for a two week trip?
I see Carnival has updated their tip policy too. Look at it here . Along with the new dress codes, this new tip policy seems much cleaner and easier to understand. I like it.
Shaza - the link above provides your answer assuming you are cruising with Carnival.
I have a comment to make. Maybe not such a grand idea but a suggestion. If you feel the $400 is more than you can afford, maybe you could 'clean up' after yourselves in your room and not leave a big mess for the steward to clean up. I've done that when my kids travelled with us.
I know they still have to make up all those beds, but if they aren't spending so much time 'picking up the cabin' then they wouldn't mind if you removed one or two of the tips for the kids.
I wouldn't remove all of them, just maybe save yourself a few dollars and adjust your expenses elsewhere. Carnival's staff really does work very hard and usually with a very pleasant attitude,so you may feel that you WANT to tip the recommended amount.
OK I'll add my 2 cents. I ALWAYS immediately go to the purser's desk and have the tips removed from my Sign & Sail account. I do them personally...I think they appreciate it more; I can adjust them for good or bad service; and I can tip who I WANT to, instead of who I'm SUPPOSED to.
I usually give $15/day to waiter (figuring it would be a $100 meal...15%) and about $2 per person per day for bus person...again providing they went out of their way to help us, which they usually do. I adjust most on cabin person...depending on what they did for me...and if I ever even SAW them! I have areal problem tipping the Maitre D if I never even saw him. I've only ever done it once...with George the Greek who alot of people know. He was the best and DESERVED it!
Please provide at least the minimum recommended gratuities. I'm still a believer that removing the tips for any reason other than poor service is not the best way to handle the tips. Even if you intend to provide them in some other way. Having them removed at the front end is a red flag to the Purser and since they are part of the crew and they do share information with the staff, it may not have the intended result you're hoping to achieve. Not ever seeing a Maitr'd, I'm speculating here, may be a direct result of removing the tips at the outset of a trip. They have policies in place that work for the cruiseline and the guests. Anytime you go around any policy/procedure set up, be prepared for there to be a potential downside. The gratuities are fair to everyone involved. Going over and above is great if you have the means and believe someone earned add'l tips for stellar service or going above and beyond in some other way. With that said, any change to the structure of the tipping policy will affect someone onboard who works hard for a living just as the people you come in contact with daily and see doing the work.
If the tips push a cruise out of the budget for your vacation, you've chosen the wrong cruise. There are daily expenses like excursions or other activities at the ports. Shopping for souveniers for friends and family back home. Drinks or drink cards are add'l expense. If you can't afford to pay these type of expenses along with the gratuities, a better cruise would have been a 3 day Bahamma cruise where you can afford the tips and to enjoy the things offered at the ports.
Neil...just a thought or 2, and you know I always value your opinions highly!
The word TIP is an acronym for TO INSURE PROMPTNESS. And who is to say that your service is supposed to be dependant on how much of a tip you're going to get. I thought you're ALWAYS supposed to give great service. I tip VERY well, but I do tip based on how much someone did for me.
Yes Steve, I agree with you as usual. It should be based on service provided. If I recieved less then adequate service I might just visit the Purser and have something adjusted. I've cruised a fair amount and have never made that trip to have a tip removed. I have had some staff that were average, a time or two perhaps slightly below average. The vast majority of the time I've had the crew members go above and beyond any expectations I'd have for service on or off a ship. As a result I feel those who simply do their job have earned the minimum. Anything over that I take care of in addition to the minimum. To take away from someone onboard something that their income and ability to support their family is based on would have to be pretty poor service from my perspective. Especially someone who works as hard as everyone onboard a cruiseship is required to work. Being blessed enough to be the one being waited on and cleaned up after, I can't really in good concience take from the livelyhood of those who are working long hours to make my vacation enjoyable. I guess I have a different standard for these folks than I would for someone that was a Maitr'd at a 5 star restaraunt at in Houston who may work 5 minutes from home, an 8 hour shift, 5 days a week and gets to go home to his family at the end of the shift. Maybe I'm to lax in my standards for tipping. That's okay with me, I have a job i love. I have a comfortable life and can enjoy a cruise from time to time without having to change my grocery budget to do so. I'm blessed but not a rich man. Sharing a little of my blessings with others who wait on me and clean up after me is not going to affect my lifestyle. It may well affect theirs.
I'd like to add a tip comment here. My daughter dances for Carnival, as such she is "Staff" and helps any guest whenever the opportunities presents itself. Whether it is simply directions or a little extra pizazz for your young daugter who dances at home. If offered a tip she would not take it. The only exception is when she works as the photo opportunity after dinner. However she is adamate about tipping those who are on the tipping list. When she takes dinner with us she tips, when the server at the fish and chips does something special for us, she tips. She knows how hard they work and how little they get without tips. Please tip the minimum unless there is something really really wrong and try to fix it first.
Posts: 501 | Location: New Hampshire | Registered: November 13, 2006
Here's what I've decided about tipping. If I don't have the money to tip, I just don't go. That includes going out to dinner at a restaurant.TIPS=TO insure proper service. Back when I first started cruising, you just put it in an envelope and gave it to the person. Now it's on the bill. My dad was leary of this afraid that they don't get the money. I reassured him that they do. Anyway, I still give more at the end of the cruise because I always get more out of a cruise than I could ever give. I met someone on a cruise years ago and was lucky enough to correspond with them for awhile. Believe me, they deserve those tips and more. The stories I heard would curl your hair. I pray that everyone will at least give the minimum and if someone does go above and beyond for you, give them a little something extra!
Carnivale 1983 SS Enchanted Isle 1992 SS Enchanted Seas 1995 SS Enchanted Seas 1996 Holiday 2005 NCL Sun 2007
I know that tipping is getting out of hand. I now see a TIP jar at the counter in a gas station. For what? Taking my money after I had to pump the gas myself.
A friend and his wife went on a cruise with his brother and sister in law. His relatives removed the TIP because they thought that it was cute as they would never see the crew again. The laugh was on them because they never seen their luggage again.
The worst one is the guy that stands at the dock to load your luggage into the container. All he does is throw it into a bin and he wants a dollar a bag. What a rip, but that is the cost of traveling. Live with it or don't go. No sympathy here.
As stated earlier; the crew works harder with passengers that have children and from what I have seen they really go out of their way to accommodate them. During your cruise I am sure that you will realize that it is worth every penny.
Originally posted by PA Steve Rocky Mount: Neil...just a thought or 2, and you know I always value your opinions highly!
The word TIP is an acronym for TO INSURE PROMPTNESS. And who is to say that your service is supposed to be dependant on how much of a tip you're going to get. I thought you're ALWAYS supposed to give great service. I tip VERY well, but I do tip based on how much someone did for me.
The best advice I can give is to treat people the way you would like to be treated. If you were working on the cruise ship, working long hard hours, and making minimum wages (or less) how would you want to be tipped? If you put it on a personal level and put yourself in the other person's shoes, let your heart make the decision for you. If you don't have a lot of money, you don't have to tip big, but do tip something. Money is tight for everyone right now, but remember you are on vacation and these people are working very hard to make your vacation the best.
I am going to add my thoughts on this post of tipping. We do know that once the workers got $5.00 a day, and I was shocked by working all day for that. Now they don't even receive that, but only work for tips. If a waiter, lets say, works 7 days a week for the whole month and if EVERYONE pays their tips at every cruise it comes out to $1,200.00 a month, but not everyone pays so it usually is only $600.00 a month. I then ask myself would I work 7 days a week for a whole month for $600.00? NOT! I pay the tipping charge and the last night give to the people who really stood out , like our waiter and bus boy an extra $20.00 each in an envelope just for them. I didn't like the cruise, but these guys worked their tails off to make it special for us.
