I know, two completely different ships. I am looking at booking either a 5 day Eastern Caribbean on the Imagination or a 6 day Western Caribbean on the Liberty this October. I would appreaciate any comments or opinions on either of these. Thanks.

I was on the Liberty over spring break. I must say, I had an amazing time! There were always things to do, and it was a very relaxing and stress-free vacation. I don't know much about the Imagination, but the Liberty is still a fairly new ship. The rooms were nice, the food was good, and the entertainment was enjoyable. I'd also say, go for the 6-day, because, hey, an extra day! But I'm sure which ever one you chose, you will have a great time!